Shelter Island, NY 2 Bedroom Homes For Sale

Hmmm, we're not finding that right now.

Save this search to get notified when we have inventory, and in the meantime, try expanding your search.

Rocket Homes›New York›Suffolk County›Shelter Island›2 Bedrooms

Shelter Island, NY Real Estate Market Overview

In December 2024 in Shelter Island, NY there were 5.9% less homes for sale than in November 2024. Listings spent 176 days on the market in December 2024, and had a median list price of $2,495,000 during the same period.

Info Icon From Rocket Homes Real Estate and based on county public records data.

Living In Shelter Island, NY

What is it like to live in Shelter Island, New York?

Shelter Island is located in Suffolk County, New York. There are roughly 2,413 residents, living in 1,134 households. The average temperature for Shelter Island this time of the year is low of 23F and high of 38F. On average, Shelter Island gets about 4.33 inches of precipitation in January. Most residents are home owners (77%), have a post secondary degree (53%) and are single, no kids (45%).

Info - Data provided by Home Junction Data provided by Home Junction

Homes For Sale Near Shelter Island, NY

Houses for sale in Southold

Housing Market Reports In Suffolk County

Schools Near Shelter Island, NY

Elementary Schools

Greenport Elementary School
720 Front St
Public District PK-6

High Schools

Shelter Island School
33 N Ferry Rd
Public District PK-12
Greenport High School
720 Front St
Public District 7-12

Info Icon Data provided by Great Schools

MLS Disclaimers & Copyright

A Verified Approval is based on an underwriter's comprehensive analysis of your credit, income, employment status, assets and debt. Does not apply to loans submitted through a mortgage broker. Conditions may apply.
Rocket Mortgage disclosures and licensing pages. External Link