ParkingAttached, Driveway, Garage Door Opener, Private
Year Built1962
HeatingENERGY STAR Qualified Equipment, Oil, Baseboard, Hot Water
CoolingCentral Air
WaterfrontCreek, Waterfront, Water Access
ViewPanoramic, Water
MLS #L3564455
StatusActive
About 5 Hagar Rd
Experience the epitome of coastal living in this meticulously maintained one-level home, nestled in a charming beach community. Renovated in 2012 by Fokine Construction, this stunning residence offers breathtaking water views of Menantic Creek from nearly every room. Inside, you'll find an open-concept floor plan featuring a vaulted living room with a cozy fireplace, a dining area, and a custom chef's kitchen. Step outside onto the waterside deck, adorned with mahogany railings and stainless wire, for a serene outdoor retreat. The primary bedroom is a true oasis, complete with two walk-in closets and a luxurious en-suite bathroom. Enjoy the tranquility of the 1.29-acre shared parcel extending into the creek. This quiet enclave offers the perfect blend of luxury and natural beauty, making it an ideal coastal retreat., Additional information: Appearance:Very Good,Green Features:Insulated Doors,Interior Features:Lr/Dr,Location Features:Protected Wetland,Separate Hotwater Heater:no
Property Details
Property Features
Property Information:
Architectural Style: Ranch
Year Built: 1962
Living Area: 3,312 SqFt
Listing Office:
Office Name: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Office Phone: (631) 749-1155
Interior Features
Interior Information:
Appliances: ENERGY STAR Qualified Dishwasher, ENERGY STAR Qualified Dryer, ENERGY STAR Qualified Refrigerator, ENERGY STAR Qualified Washer, Dishwasher, Dryer, Microwave, Refrigerator, Washer
Parking: Attached, Driveway, Garage Door Opener, Private
Lot Features
Lot Information:
Lot: Corner Lot, Sloped
Utilities
Utilities Information:
Heating: ENERGY STAR Qualified Equipment, Oil, Baseboard, Hot Water
Cooling: Central Air
Other
Directions Information:
Directions: Take Menantic Rd. South to Hagar Rd, turn left onto Hagar and continue straight. As the road bends, continue straight onto Dickerson Drive and this home is on your left.
Price Information
Listing Price Info
Price Summary:
List Price: $2,745,000
Price Per SqFt: $829/SqFt
Tax Information:
Annual Amount: $5,831
Tax Year: 2020
What can I afford?
Understand what home price range makes sense for your budget.
Housing Market Comparison
See how this home compares to others in Shelter Island, NY.
This property is $250K more than the Median List Price and $46/SqFt less than other homes in Shelter Island, NY.
Based on homes listed in the last 12 months
MLS Details
MLS Information:
MLS Name: ONEKEY2
MLS Number: #L3564455
Listing Office:
Office Name: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Office Phone: (631) 749-1155
Listings courtesy of OneKey MLS as distributed by MLS GRID.
All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.
The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program of the OneKey™ MLS. Real Estate listings held by brokerage firms other than this broker are marked with the Broker Reciprocity logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing brokers. This information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use, that it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
The source of the displayed data is either the property owner or public record provided by non-governmental third parties. It is believed to be reliable but not guaranteed.
Information Copyright 2025, OneKey™ MLS. All Rights Reserved. Data displayed may be a portion of, and not a complete set of all listings published in the MLS.
This advertisement does not suggest that the broker has a listing in this property or properties or that any property is currently available. Last updated on: 1/2/2025, 9:11:50 AM Eastern. If you have any questions regarding the accuracy of this data, please contact us at help@rockethomes.com.
Property Sales & Tax
Tax History
YEAR
PROP. TAX
ASSESSMENT
2020
$5,831
$940,000
2019
$2,860
$938,000
2018
-
$935,000
History based on county public records data.
Payment Calculator
Calculate your estimated monthly expenses for this listing. Play with the values below to better understand your monthly payment and utilities.
$13.7K
Per Month
Principal & Interest
$13.7K
Home PriceThe dollar amount you pay for the home.
$
Interest RateMortgage interest rates fluctuate, but they're typically in the 5% to 9% range. Your rate will be calculated based on personal details including your credit score.
%
Down PaymentThe initial money paid at closing that is usually a percentage of the purchase price. Most loans require at least 3% down, but a 0% down payment may be possible if you're eligible for a VA or USDA loan.
$%
Loan TermThis is how long you'll pay on the loan. A longer term gives you smaller payments, while a shorter term saves you money on interest.
Property Taxes
$0
Property Taxes -Annual CostEvery homeowner pays taxes to their local government based on their home's value and the property tax rates for the county or city. Most areas charge property taxes semiannually.
$/ Year
Mortgage Insurance
$0
Mortgage Insurance -Monthly PremiumMortgage insurance helps secure a mortgage with a lower down payment. It typically costs 0.1% - 2% of your loan amount per year.
$/ Month
Homeowners Insurance
$67
Homeowners Insurance -Monthly PremiumMost homeowners pay about $1,000 a year for homeowners insurance, but the cost varies based on your location, home and coverage.
$/ Month
Homeowners Association (HOA)
$0
Homeowners Association -Monthly FeesHomeowners Association (HOA) fees can range from $30 per month to $500+ per month. Be sure to ask your agent about HOA fees on a home as it can impact your affordability or check the online home listing.
$/ Month
Utilities
$0
Utilities - Monthly CostYou'll need to budget for utilities as a homeowner, which typically includes water and sewer, gas and electric, internet and cable. Cost will depend on your location and the size of your home. On a monthly basis, Americans pay $239 - $442 per month.
$/ Month
Recommended Financing
30-Year Fixed
Rate/APR
7.5% / 6.68%
Total Monthly Payment
$8,296
Schools
Schools Nearby
The school rating is a score out of 10, where 10 is the highest and 1 is the lowest. Assigned schools have a bold outline.
We're sorry, we currently don't have assigned school data for this listing.
Nearby Schools
3
/10
Greenport Elementary School
720 Front St
Distance between this listing and this school3.09 miles
Public District Grades PK-6
7
/10
Southold Elementary School
420 Oaklawn Ave
Distance between this listing and this school4.27 miles
Public District Grades KG-6
6
/10
Sag Harbor Elementary School
68 Hampton St
Distance between this listing and this school5.34 miles
Public District Grades PK-5
Nearby Schools
5
/10
Springs School
48 School St
Distance between this listing and this school10.44 miles
Public District Grades PK-8
6
/10
East Hampton Middle School
76 Newtown Ln
Distance between this listing and this school10.56 miles
Public District Grades 6-8
6
/10
Tuckahoe School
468 Magee St
Distance between this listing and this school11.68 miles
Public District Grades PK-8
Nearby Schools
5
/10
Shelter Island School
33 N Ferry Rd
Distance between this listing and this school0.75 miles
Public District Grades PK-12
3
/10
Greenport High School
720 Front St
Distance between this listing and this school3.09 miles
Public District Grades 7-12
4
/10
Southold Jr. / Sr. High School
420 Oaklawn Ave
Distance between this listing and this school4.39 miles
The neighbors living near this home have an average income of $74,627. Typical income of Shelter Island, NY residents is between $35k-100k annually. Residents typically live in single, no kids family. Most residents in this area have post secondary degree education.
All data provided by Home Junction and Claritas
Frequently Asked Questions About 5 Hagar Rd
What is the listing price of this property?
The listing price of 5 Hagar Rd property is $2,745,000.
What type of property is this?
The property 5 Hagar Rd is a house located in Shelter Island, New York, 11964.
Is this property for sale now?
Active Listing: 5 Hagar Rd is For Sale (Active/New) which means the seller is accepting offers.
What is the annual property tax for this property?
According to the records, the last property tax for 2020 is $5,831 (source: MLS/based on county public records data).
How many bedrooms and bathrooms does this property have?
The property at 5 Hagar Rd has 3 bedrooms and 2 full and 1 half bathrooms.
What is the square footage of this property?
The property 5 Hagar Rd is 3,312 SqFt (source: MLS/tax record).
By checking this box and submitting your personal information, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You also expressly consent to having Rocket Homes Real Estate LLC, its Family of Companies, Rocket Homes Network Partners, and potentially our mortgage partners contact you about your inquiry by text message or phone (including automatic telephone dialing system, AI voice, or an artificial or prerecorded voice) to the residential or cellular telephone number you have provided, even if that telephone number is on a corporate, state, or national Do Not Call Registry. You do not have to agree to receive such calls or messages as a condition of getting any services from Rocket Homes Real Estate, LLC or its partners. By communicating with us by phone, you consent to calls being recorded and monitored. You also agree that we can share your personal data and contact information with third parties such as mortgage partners, partner companies, and affiliates, and that these parties may use your personal data and contact information for marketing and analytic purposes, and to improve your experience.
This home is located at 5 Hagar Rd in Shelter Island, NY and zip code 11964. This 3,312 square foot home was built in 1962. Features: 3 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms. It has been listed on Rocket Homes since July 09, 2024 and is currently priced at $2,745,000.
The number of homes for sale in Shelter Island, NY decreased by 5.9% between November 2024 and December 2024. While the average time on the market in December 2024 was 176 days, the median list price was $2,495,000.
From Rocket Homes Real Estate and based on county public records data.
Listings courtesy of OneKey MLS as distributed by MLS GRID.
The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program of the OneKey™ MLS. Real Estate listings held by brokerage firms other than this broker are marked with the Broker Reciprocity logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing brokers. This information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use, that it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. 
Hunting
Hunting
Figure Skating
NASCAR
Dillards
Dick's Sporting Goods
Dollar General
Cracker Barrel
Texas Roadhouse
Applebees
Cadillac
Subaru
Ram
News/Talk/Information
New Country
Classic Country